Reflections on Summer-ing in Israel

Wednesday, June 28, 2006

Israel Must Act Now

I just submitted this letter to the New York Times. If it's not published there at least I can still express my disdain for Secretary Rice's cursory regard for the situation.

After spending weeks digging a tunnel and ultimately ambushing an Israeli checkpoint, Palestinian extremists left two soldiers dead, four injured, and one of the injured kidnapped. In response, Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice counseled the Israeli government “not to let the situation escalate, and to give diplomacy a chance to work to try to get this release,” according to the NYTimes article entitled “Israeli Troops Enter Gaza; Bridges Are Hit.” While this is a great idea in an ideal world, it fails to account for the reality of the situation.

During the construction of the tunnels by the militant extremists, Israeli Prime Minister Olmert was attempting to negotiate the Prisoner’s Agreement to establish a peace plan with President of the Palestinian Authority Mahmoud Abbas and other Palestinian leaders. Israel was seeking a democratic resolution to the situation, while the extremists were continuing with their plan of attack. Now in order to have some bargaining power, another Israeli youth has been kidnapped and the spokesman for the responsible group is claiming that the boy will be “butchered in front of TV cameras,” according to Haaretz. Israel should not wait for another child to be kidnapped in order to negotiate with dishonest extremists. Israel must use its military might to control the situation before it escalates further.

Sunday, June 18, 2006

Settling into Israeli Life and Questioning Extremism

After a week in Israel, my anxiety has decreased substantially, my constant startle response has waned, and I am starting to welcome and freely explore my environment. While at first put off by the constant presence of guns, they are now a source of comfort for me. And, of course, they are a necessary preventative measure. Daily terror attacks are thwarted by the presence of these guards. When I was sitting in Mike's Place, an American bar located next to the U.S. Embassy, I was not afraid to be sitting there. Although a suicide bomber blew himself up in there a few years ago, I could not help but think about how safe I felt there. I am in Israel, and I feel at home.

Now, that does not mean that I am not afraid of extremists. Actually, I'm afraid of radicals on both sides of the spectrum; however, I guess I have to admit that I'm more afraid of radical Muslims (note the distinction between Muslims and radical Muslims) due to their indoctrination of hatred towards the Jews beginning in their early childhood. I saw a documentary last week entitled "Obsession: Radical Islam's War against the West," which exposed to me the breadth and depth of the hatred. Essentially from birth, many Muslim children are taught to fear and ultimately hate Jews. This fear and hatred are so strong as to make violence and terror acceptable mechanisms in their minds.

How do such ideas work, you wonder? Well, so do I.

It's been documented that from early childhood, toddler-hood essentially, children are taught that Jews are like apes and pigs and that they desire to kill and eat children. For example, on one recent television series, the Muslim actors portrayed Jewish ones slaying an innocent Christian child in order to include the child's blood in their Passover matzah. Many Muslims see this program during Ramadan, a time during which many families gather around the television, and it furthers their fear which they then transform into hatred. This type of programming coincides with the regular programming of sheiks and other religious leaders who claim to be representing the desires of Allah by demanding the death of the Jews and multicultural societies like the West. They also blatantly call for taking over the world and killing any and all people who are not Muslim.

These leaders not only incite and provoke violence, but they teach youngsters that the noblest action for them to strive in life is to become a suicide bomber. During their initiation ceremony for training, the youths must strap a bomb to themselves.

This whole process has me quite puzzled for two major reasons: 1) it relies entirely on false, misguided information and 2) it is a religion that actively promotes violence and widespread murder. The hatred of the Jewish people and westerners is based upon what? The belief that Jews use the blood of children? Of course this is a completely fallacious statement. Instead, the hatred is based upon the religious leaders' pronouncements of the evils inherent in the Jewish people. These accusations lack substantiation; however, they are freely and repeatedly promulgated throughout the Arab world. And, the Jewish position is not permitted to be expressed. Did you know that if an Iranian blogger were caught even writing the word "Israel" in his blog, he would be sentenced to ten years in prison? In the radical-controlled Middle Eastern world, only one side of the story is presented.

As for the anomaly of religion calling for death, this is one I do not even know where to begin. I cannot understand the rationale behind training youths to commit suicide in the name of Allah, when the elders who call for such extremist actions fail to follow their own words. Actions really do speak louder than words. How can religion demand murder? How can a person be pure if he or she kills other people? But really the question for me is how can anyone believe that G-d would ask for people to kill others?

Regardless of the lack of logic surrounding these ideas is the fact that the tiny state of Israel is surrounded by Muslim nations, each with factions of radicals. In order to protect its citizenry, one measure taken by the State of Israel was to erect the Security Fence. The rate of attacks from terrorists in the West Bank has dropped substantially as a result of this fence, more than proving its worth. Although the State of Israel would rather not need the fence, it is needed at the current time.

According to Nonie Darwish, the daughter of a shaheed, the Arab world has been surrounding the State of Israel since its inception with a psychological fence. The Arabs must tear down the psychological barrier before the physical fence can go.

Wednesday, June 14, 2006

First Impressions

Note: I created this blog on Monday, June 12, (originally at http://reflections-on-summer-in-israel.blogspot.com/) intending to share my thoughts, and I hope to be quite open about them. I would appreciate hearing your perspective on some of the issues I discuss, so please post responses.

I arrived in Israel last Friday full of anticipation and anxiety. Of course my mother, like any mother, was nervous about my trip to the Middle East, so I had to play it cool, pretend like I was not worried about the tensions so she couldn't convince me not to come. I really don't think that would have happened, but now that I'm here and attacks seem to be escalating, my nerves are a bit unsettled.

Yesterday was the first day in the office. For those of you who are unfamiliar with life in the Middle East, the work week begins on Sunday and ends on Thursday. The bosses tried to emphasize our need for caution. Case in point: The other day a student visited an area outside of Israeli control and was kidnapped. Luckily he was an American and was not abducted by a terrorist organization without regard for the might of the United States, and once his identity as a U.S. citizen was confirmed, he was released. I don't know that I've ever felt more relieved to hold a piece of documentation.

Of course the situation does not consist exclusively of attacks by the Palestinians against Jews. I'm sure you've heard about the killing of al-Zarkawi and the killing of a leader of the Palestinian Revolutionary Committee (PRC), which attacked an American convoy in 2003 and serves as Hamas' private militia. The Americans took credit for the first attack, and the Israelis claim that the second was a coincidence, that the base was being targeted not the leader. A tragic killing occurred on the beach in Gaza, where it appears that a stray Israeli shell misfired. (The Israeli Defense Force (IDF) statement on this shelling has yet to be released.) The retaliation from the Palestinians has started in full force, however, as 54 rockets have been launched against Sderot from Gaza since Friday.

It is difficult to objectively dissect the media here, and so I will attempt not to do so at the current time. All media here appears to be wholly biased and often factually incorrect. It is difficult to know which sources are reliable around the world, but particularly here in the Middle East.

Basically, my first impressions have given me reason to be constantly alert. Alert to not only potential physical danger I might find myself in, but also alert to the biases of the media.